An antenuptial contract excluding accrual can have a significant impact on how assets are dealt with when a marriage ends. But does it mean that one spouse can never claim a share of the other’s pension interest?
A landmark Constitutional Court judgment has changed the legal position for certain marriages out of community of property without accrual. In GD v Minister of Home Affairs and Others, the Court declared section 7(7)(c) of the Divorce Act unconstitutional and invalid.
The ruling removes a significant legal barrier to including pension interest in redistribution claims during divorce proceedings. It also highlights an important distinction: being married without accrual does not necessarily mean that pension interest can never be considered when a marriage ends.
What does it mean to be married without accrual?
When spouses marry out of community of property without accrual, their estates generally remain separate during the marriage and are not automatically combined upon divorce.
Unlike a marriage with accrual, there is no automatic sharing of the growth in the spouses’ respective estates. Each spouse generally retains their own assets, subject to applicable legal principles and any valid agreements.
However, the Divorce Act provides a mechanism through which a court may, in qualifying circumstances, order the redistribution of assets between spouses when granting a divorce.
This is particularly relevant where one spouse may have made substantial contributions to the marriage without accumulating assets or retirement savings in their own name.
Why was pension interest treated differently?
Section 7(7)(a) of the Divorce Act generally provides that a spouse’s pension interest is deemed to form part of their assets when determining the patrimonial benefits to which the parties may be entitled in divorce proceedings.
Section 7(7)(c), however, excluded this provision in divorce actions involving marriages concluded on or after 1 November 1984 under antenuptial contracts excluding community of property, community of profit and loss, and accrual.
This created an obstacle for spouses seeking redistribution of pension interest, even where the broader redistribution remedy was available.
The distinction became increasingly difficult to justify following the Constitutional Court’s earlier decision in EB (born S) v ER (born B); KG v Minister of Home Affairs and Others, which addressed the availability of redistribution claims in marriages concluded after 1 November 1984.
What did the Constitutional Court decide?
The matter concerned a woman who had married out of community of property without accrual in 2004. She alleged that she had focused on managing the family and supporting her husband’s business and personal endeavours during the marriage.
When the marriage broke down, she sought, among other relief, redistribution of assets that included her husband’s pension interest.
The Constitutional Court confirmed that section 7(7)(c) was unconstitutional. It found that the provision maintained an irrational distinction between spouses in marriages concluded before and after 1 November 1984 and unfairly discriminated on the grounds of gender.
The Court recognised that unpaid domestic work, childcare, and household expenses are disproportionately borne by women. These contributions can enable the other spouse to devote more time and financial resources to career advancement and retirement savings.
The judgment confirms that direct financial contributions are not the only contributions that may matter when a court considers a just and equitable redistribution of assets.
Does this mean you are automatically entitled to your spouse’s pension interest?
No. The judgment does not create an automatic right to half of a spouse’s pension interest.
Instead, it removes the statutory exclusion that prevented pension interest from being considered in the relevant redistribution claims.
A spouse seeking redistribution must still establish a proper basis for relief under the applicable provisions of the Divorce Act. The court must consider the circumstances of the marriage, the nature of the contributions made by each spouse, and whether redistribution would be just and equitable.
For example, one spouse may have spent years caring for the children and managing the household while the other built a business and accumulated retirement benefits. Those circumstances may be relevant to a redistribution claim, but the outcome will depend on the evidence and the applicable legal requirements.
The court must consider the facts of each case. The existence of an antenuptial contract excluding accrual remains relevant, but it is no longer sufficient to rely on section 7(7)(c) as a blanket exclusion of pension interest in the affected category of marriages.
What about divorces that have already been finalised?
The Constitutional Court’s order does not retrospectively disturb the legal consequences of acts, omissions, or facts existing before the order was made in relation to marriages concluded on or after 1 November 1984.
The judgment therefore does not reopen finalised divorce proceedings or matrimonial estates that have already been wound up.
For spouses whose divorce proceedings are still underway, however, the judgment may have important implications. The relevance of pension interest should be assessed in light of the pleadings, the relief sought, the stage of the proceedings, and any settlement already reached.
Legal advice is particularly important before changing an existing claim or attempting to revisit a settlement.
What should you do if you are considering divorce?
If you are married out of community of property without accrual, do not assume that the terms of your antenuptial contract answer every question about your potential rights on divorce.
The Constitutional Court’s judgment makes it important to consider the full financial circumstances of the marriage, including pension interests, contributions to the household, childcare responsibilities, and support provided to a spouse’s career or business.
Equally, if you have accumulated substantial pension benefits, you should understand how a redistribution claim may affect your financial position.
At Francois Pienaar Attorneys, we assist clients with divorce proceedings, matrimonial property disputes, and the negotiation of settlement agreements. We can help you understand your rights and obligations in light of the latest developments in South African family law.
Contact our team for advice tailored to your circumstances.