Buying or selling a business involves more than agreeing on a purchase price. One of the first and most important decisions is whether the transaction should involve the sale of shares in a company or the sale of the business itself. The structure you choose can have significant tax, legal and financial consequences.
Buying or Selling Shares vs the Business
When a business operates through a company, a seller may either sell the shares in that company or sell the business and its assets to the purchaser.
In a share sale, the purchaser acquires ownership of the company by purchasing its shares. The company continues to exist, along with its existing assets, contracts, obligations and potential liabilities.
In an asset sale, the purchaser acquires the business or specified assets directly from the company. The transaction can be structured to identify which assets, contracts and obligations will transfer to the purchaser.
Neither option is automatically better. The appropriate structure depends on the nature of the business, the parties’ objectives, and the relevant tax and legal considerations.
What Should Buyers Consider?
For a purchaser, one of the main risks of buying shares is inheriting a company with undisclosed debts, outstanding creditor claims or potential legal disputes. Even a business that appears profitable may have liabilities that are not immediately apparent.
An asset sale may offer greater control over what the purchaser acquires and can reduce exposure to certain historical liabilities. However, it does not automatically provide complete protection against creditor claims or other obligations.
Where applicable, section 34 of the Insolvency Act 24 of 1936 requires notice of certain sales of businesses to be published in the Government Gazette and specified newspapers. Failure to comply with the statutory requirements can have serious consequences, including potential liability for the purchaser in respect of the seller’s debts.
The transaction must therefore be structured and implemented carefully, including compliance with applicable legislation and consideration of any contracts, employees, licences and other obligations that may be affected.
What Should Sellers Consider?
For sellers, a share sale may offer tax advantages in certain circumstances. For example, selling shares may avoid the need for the company to distribute the sale proceeds to its shareholders, which could otherwise trigger dividends tax, depending on how the proceeds are dealt with.
However, the tax implications depend on the particular transaction, the parties involved and the applicable tax rules. Sellers should obtain appropriate tax advice before deciding on the structure.
Get the Structure Right From the Start
Whether you are buying or selling a business, the transaction should be carefully planned before an agreement is signed. Due diligence, the purchase agreement, the treatment of liabilities and compliance with statutory requirements all play an important role in protecting the parties’ interests.
The right legal advice at the outset can help you manage risk, avoid costly surprises and ensure that the transaction is structured appropriately. At Francois Pienaar Attorneys, we assist with the legal structuring and implementation of business sales and acquisitions.